Adolescents’ Learning of Civics in Second-Language Classrooms: Opportunities and Difficulties from a Student Perspective

This submission has open access
Abstract Summary

The aim of this study is to explore what difficulties and opportunities second-language (L2) students in grade nine, perceive when reading texts in civics. The data is based on thirty-six Think Aloud (TA) and exit interviews with eighteen L2 students in grade nine, aged 14-15. A four-field model is constructed and presented to demonstrate that the four key components of a) literacy abilities, b) disciplinary literacy abilities, c) prior knowledge, d) content area knowledge, and their interaction with each other are central for supporting L2 students' civics learning and literacy development. In this study, the four-field model is used as an analytical tool and a conceptual framework for analyzing the difficulties and opportunities that L2 students perceive and express when they read two civics-specific texts. Findings indicate that making a distinction between literacy abilities and disciplinary literacy abilities is difficult for all participants. The difficulties with civics texts are mainly in relation to (a) high degree of civics-specific terms and everyday words (b) dense content, (c) long text passages, (d) few or hidden clues, (e) ambiguous pictures, and (f) insufficient prior knowledge about the main topic.

Submission ID :
AILA158
Submission Type
Argument :

In civic education, the reading of texts in textbooks is crucial, and it is reasonable to think that the students' possibilities to understand the content of the texts play a role in their learning in civics. However, knowledge about the opportunities and difficulties for the students' meaning-making needs to include not only linguistic aspects of the reading but also perspectives of the role of students' prior knowledge when they face texts in civics. This knowledge is important to develop, to be able to work scaffolding in the classroom when civics is taught.

In fact, when L2 students' challenges in civics classrooms are discussed, students' level of prior knowledge and literacy abilities are pointed out as two factors that matter for L2 students' goal achievement in civics (Lai, 2018; Gibson, 2017; Deltac, 2012). In addition, studies that underline the importance of prior knowledge for content learning also emphasize that this knowledge needs to be assessed and activated to support students' content-area learning (Jaffee, 2016; Vacca, Vacca & Mraz, 2014). 

Regarding literacy abilities, their role in content-area learning has been studied from various perspectives. For instance, from a form-focused perspective, the language forms and structures in the texts are studied in order to facilitate L2 students with language barriers, such as difficulties with reading comprehension due to complex sentences, dense content, and understanding of the content-specific concepts (Schleppegrell, 2012; Shanahan & Shanahan, 2008, 2012). With a form-focused perspective, there is a risk of students using literacy abilities without having a comprehensive understanding of the purpose of a text and how to read it (Moje, 2015). 

In order to integrate the form with the content, content-focused activities are suggested by scholars within the field of disciplinary literacy, who claim that the tasks in content area classrooms should be designed to support both language and content area learning (Echevarria, Vogt & Short, 2017; Yoder, Kibler & van Hover, 2016; de Schonewise & Klinger, 2012). For instance, when it comes to reading and learning from texts, L2 students need to activate their reading abilities not only for decoding the texts, but also for decontextualizing and understanding the main concepts and identifying important passages in texts that are often written in an academic language using content-specific terms and abstract concepts. For those students who are in the process of learning an L2 and have not yet received enough opportunities to develop their L1 and L2, the process of learning from the discipline-specific contexts in social studies can be experienced as more challenging.

Against this background, I argue that that the four key components of a) literacy abilities, b) disciplinary literacy abilities, c) prior knowledge, d) content area knowledge, and their interaction with each other are central for supporting L2 students' civics learning and literacy development. 

PhD candidate
,
University of Gothenburg

Similar Abstracts by Type

Submission ID
Submission Title
Submission Topic
Submission Type
Primary Author
AILA851
[SYMP59] OPEN CALL - Language & holistic ecology
Oral Presentation
She/Her Aliyah Morgenstern
AILA911
[SYMP17] Adult Migrants Acquiring Basic Literacy Skills in a Second Language
Oral Presentation
She/Her Kaatje Dalderop
AILA990
[SYMP17] Adult Migrants Acquiring Basic Literacy Skills in a Second Language
Oral Presentation
She/Her MOUTI ANNA
AILA484
[SYMP47] Literacies in CLIL: subject-specific language and beyond
Oral Presentation
She/Her Natalia Evnitskaya
AILA631
[SYMP15] AILA ReN Social cohesion at work: shared languages as mortar in professional settings
Oral Presentation
He/Him Henrik Rahm
AILA583
[SYMP24] Changing perspectives towards multilingual education: teachers, learners and researchers as agents of social cohesion
Oral Presentation
She/Her Alessandra Periccioli
AILA238
[SYMP81] Reflections on co-production as a research practice in the field of foreign language teaching and learning
Oral Presentation
She/Her Martina Zimmermann
AILA290
[SYMP36] Fluency as a multilingual practice: Concepts and challenges
Oral Presentation
He/Him Shungo Suzuki
23 hits