Dismantling standard English ideology through ELF instructions

This submission has open access
Abstract Summary

Previous studies on Chinese university students' attitudes towards English language and English learning reveal that standard English ideology (SEI) is prevalent and entrenched. Participants expressed their belief in the Anglo-American ownership of English and desirability to achieve native-like proficiency. These mentalities reinforce the unbalanced power relation between non-native learners and native speakers, which results in inefficiency in communicative competence development, especially with English being used globally. This study examined the impact of a 32-hour intervention program on dismantling SEI among 19 Chinese university  students. The program, designed within English as a Lingua Franca (ELF) paradigm, aimed to raise students' critical awareness of the heterogeneity of English language and legitimacy of ELF speakers, through instructions of sociolinguistic realities, activities to engage students in critical reflection, and authentic online ELF practice. Data elicited from pre- and post- questionnaires suggested an overall positive result, with statistically significant differences found in the participants' perceptions of standard English. Post-intervention interviews provided detailed accounts of students' perspectives on the different components in the program and how they contributed to attitudinal changes. Based on synthesized data, the study proposed pedagogical approaches to emancipate university ELF learners from SEI.

Submission ID :
AILA266
Submission Type
Argument :

This study is part of a project that seeks to document and evaluate the effects of instructions of English as a Lingua Franca (ELF) on Chinese university students' awareness level of ELF and attitudes towards English language and English learning. It anticipates to transform students' perspectives from believing in Anglo-American centricity to acknowledging the legitimacy of English varieties and embracing being multilingual ELF speakers. The intervention program was designed under Sifakis's ELF awareness framework (2019) and informed by previous empirical studies that endeavored to challenge students' assumptions shaped by native-speaker-defined English language teaching (ELT) (e.g. Fang & Ren, 2018; Galloway, 2017; Wang, 2015)

As mentioned in the abstract, the study employed pre- and post-intervention surveys. Both quantitative and qualitative data revealed that the belief of Anglo-American English being the standard English was challenged. Based on the interview data, most students after the intervention realized that there was no standard English accent. Many of them also expressed an increased awareness of the legitimate diversity in English language and changed view towards so-called non-standard accents, recognizing their relevance to convey local culture and identity. However, some attitudes remained unchanged. For example, students still preferred the Anglo-American orientation to teaching models. Some students explained that this persistence was shaped by societal level perceptions of a successful learner of English. 

In the interview, students were invited to share what content/activities in the intervention lead to changes in perceptions. Four themes were identified. Explicit instructions of the sociolinguistic reality updated their knowledge of English language, which include the non-existence of an institutionally established standard accent, statistics regarding English language speakers' profile, and diversity in spoken English across the world and within an English-speaking country. Class activities such as group discussions provided opportunities for students to engage in real English communications, from which some realized their Chinese-accented English can actually function well. Debates, another type of activities, prompted students to reflect on related topics, e.g. the prevalence of English in China, pushing them to consider the issue more thoroughly and critically. Materials that presented successful and credible ELF models provoked learners to re-examine their learning goals. Online ELF practice provided opportunities to students to communicate with non-native speakers, the successful experience of which challenged their stereotypical views on non-native speakers and prompted students to question the necessity of imitating so-called standard accents.


Fang, F., & Ren, W. (2018). Developing students' awareness of Global Englishes. ELT Journal, 72(4), 384-394. doi:10.1093/elt/ccy012

Galloway, N. (2017). Global Englishes and change in English language teaching: Attitudes and impact: Routledge.

Wang, Y. (2015). Language awareness and ELF perceptions of Chinese university students. In International Perspectives on English as a Lingua Franca (pp. 96-116): Springer.

PhD candidate
,
University of Hong Kong

Similar Abstracts by Type

Submission ID
Submission Title
Submission Topic
Submission Type
Primary Author
AILA851
[SYMP59] OPEN CALL - Language & holistic ecology
Oral Presentation
She/Her Aliyah Morgenstern
AILA911
[SYMP17] Adult Migrants Acquiring Basic Literacy Skills in a Second Language
Oral Presentation
She/Her Kaatje Dalderop
AILA990
[SYMP17] Adult Migrants Acquiring Basic Literacy Skills in a Second Language
Oral Presentation
She/Her MOUTI ANNA
AILA484
[SYMP47] Literacies in CLIL: subject-specific language and beyond
Oral Presentation
She/Her Natalia Evnitskaya
AILA631
[SYMP15] AILA ReN Social cohesion at work: shared languages as mortar in professional settings
Oral Presentation
He/Him Henrik Rahm
AILA583
[SYMP24] Changing perspectives towards multilingual education: teachers, learners and researchers as agents of social cohesion
Oral Presentation
She/Her Alessandra Periccioli
AILA238
[SYMP81] Reflections on co-production as a research practice in the field of foreign language teaching and learning
Oral Presentation
She/Her Martina Zimmermann
AILA290
[SYMP36] Fluency as a multilingual practice: Concepts and challenges
Oral Presentation
He/Him Shungo Suzuki
37 hits